• Subscribe to our Daily News Emails
  • Advertise
    • Media Info
    • Terms & Conditions for Advertisers
    • Mechanical Data

Broadband TV News

Independent. Since 2003

  • Home
  • News Line
    • Central & East Europe
    • People
  • TV
    • On Demand/VOD
    • IPTV
    • Cable
    • Satellite
    • Terrestrial
    • Distribution
  • Business
  • Tech
  • Events
    • Events Diary
    • BTN Events
    • Events Coverage
    • Submit the details of your event
  • Features
  • Resources
    • White Papers

Societies to appeal Telenet rights decision

April 18, 2011 12.27 Europe/London By Robert Briel

The Belgian copyright societies SACD and SCAM are to appeal against the decison by the Belgian court of first instance in Mechelen over payments made by the cable operator Telenet. It is believed other societies and associations involved will follow suit.

On April 12, the court ruled that Telenet does not have to pay any additional rights to collecting societies. “This is a “first level” decision;” a spokesperson for SACD and SCAM told Broadband TV News. “It is already certain that the author’s societies will go to the “second level” due to the fact that they can’t agree with the Tribunal who made legal mistakes and a pure theoretical decision in favour of the Mechelen based branch of Liberty Global.”

According to the two societies, no facts were discussed or even examined by the court. They claim three examples. “It is factually wrong that RTL-TVI is only broadcast to the cable networks. It is a mistake to speak about “direct injection”: we found a technical scheme, from Telenet itself, showing that the signals coming from the broadcasters are reworked, packaged in bouquets and retransmitted. The Court speaks about ARI contracts… which do not exist for the period discussed. The court did not even ask LG-Telenet to show the contracts.”

According to the societies “the court used the old idea promoted by cable companies since the 1970s that “cable is a transporter”, like telecoms for private communication. And it confused broadcasting over satellite and cable distribution EU regulations. This is exactly the “coditel case” known as “Le boucher” too.

The difference is that distribution of media services is now well defined in media legislations: it is the activity of companies who sell their own packages of radio-TV services to their subscribers. A distributor is different from a network operator that provides technical networks for professionals. The difference is easy to check. Distributors sell their services to the audience, network operators sell their services to broadcasters and distributors of media.”

The audiovisual author’s societies also point to the fact that Telenet collects a distribution fee for €121.77 per year plus copyright payments for each subscription of €32.52 per year. “This total of €354,867,000… not few pennies…. if this is not an exploitation of protected works, what means the basic principle of all copyright laws: give a share of the exploitation to the rights owners.”

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Related

Filed Under: Newsline, Regulation, Top Story Tagged With: Telenet Edited: 21 April 2011 08:51

Avatar photo

About Robert Briel

Arnhem-based Robert covers the Benelux, France, Germany, Austria and Switzerland as well as IPTV, web TV, connected TV and OTT. Email Robert at rbriel@broadbandtvnews.com.

Latest News

  • Must carry introduced for Flemish media apps
  • Icelandic partnership between Síminn and HBO
  • Italy’s Piracy Shield could breach EU Digital Services Act
  • Two arrested in Midlands streaming investigation 
  • ProSiebenSat.1 secures Hollywood content deal with NBC Universal

Most Popular

  • Italy’s Piracy Shield could breach EU Digital Services Act
    Italy’s Piracy Shield could breach EU Digital Services Act
  • Prime Video to distribute france.tv channels and content
    Prime Video to distribute france.tv channels and content
  • Icelandic partnership between Síminn and HBO
    Icelandic partnership between Síminn and HBO
  • DAZN picks up international rights to Serie A 
    DAZN picks up international rights to Serie A 
  • ProSiebenSat.1 secures Hollywood content deal with NBC Universal
    ProSiebenSat.1 secures Hollywood content deal with NBC Universal
  • Must carry introduced for Flemish media apps
    Must carry introduced for Flemish media apps
  • Two arrested in Midlands streaming investigation 
    Two arrested in Midlands streaming investigation 

White Paper

Eutelsat planning capital increase to become European Starlink

The French state has bolstered its take in Eutelsat as part of a €1.35 billion capital increase. … [Download the White Paper ...]

Broadband TV News

  • Subscribe
  • About us
  • Contacts
  • Logos & Pictures
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Advertising

  • Media Info
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Mechanical Data
  • Video Services

News

  • Latest
  • Central & East Europe
  • TV
  • Tech
  • Streaming
  • Cable
  • Satellite
  • Terrestrial
  • IPTV
  • Business
  • People

Events

  • Events Diary
  • BTN Events
  • Submit the details of your event
  • Media Meet & Greet

Editorial

PO Box 499
Cambridge
United Kingdom
CB1 0AH
news@broadbandtvnews.com

Commercial

Arundel View Cottage
Wepham
West Sussex
BN18 9RA
sales@broadbandtvnews.com

Connect with Us

 

Copyright © 2025 Broadband TV News LLP · Log in

 

Loading Comments...
 

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.